40 Comments

Aw jeez ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Expand full comment

Maybe my favorite Decemberists song. I always assumed it was about comforting someone after a funeral (given the dust/stone/bones/decay/chapel imagery.)

My favorite interpretation of the '$53 bucks' line by far was from an old message board discussing the song:

"The first Halo game by Bungie (now Mircrosoft) was released on November 15th, 2001; while Castaways and Cutouts was released on May 21, 2002. The game had a suggested retail price of around $50. But with tax, it came to be around $53."

Please, Colin, tell me this is somehow cannon.

Expand full comment
Nov 29, 2022·edited Nov 29, 2022

Not to suggest Carson do additional labor but it would be a hoot to see her illustrated interpretation of the hot dog pier fire photo as you describe it here.

Thanks as always for sharing all this detail, it makes listening to these annotated songs feel brand new again and makes me appreciate them all the more.

Expand full comment

Wait

Wait

The song as about you both pining for OTHER PEOPLE????

My whole world just fell apart 💔

Expand full comment

I love vinegar/curl. It's slant, but only just a titch. They really do almost rhyme! Great post! 11/10

Expand full comment

Home with a fever, I will now think of chicken ghosts singing “Marley and Marley.”

Expand full comment

But the Muppet Christmas Carol version, right?

Expand full comment

The one and only.

Expand full comment

I used to sing the line as "sweet Autumn green-eyed girl", before I knew better.

Expand full comment

I did, too!

Expand full comment

Same! :)

Expand full comment

Good mondegreen

Expand full comment

I LOVED this, getting read the background and messages behind the lyrics. It's fun to hear about your beginnings with Carson. Please share more of these! Thank you!

Expand full comment

It is strangely comforting to read about your own sad, sad times while I am experiencing my own sad, sad times, where I am infuriatingly broke and stuck in a state I can no longer afford.

This is one of my favorites. Thank you for sharing the annotation. I always love to learn the little stories behind these songs.

I would also live to hear the story of how you and Carson got together someday. It sounds like a fun and romantic story.

Expand full comment

Ooooh , SECOND on the story of how Colarson.... Carlin.... the two of you got together!

Expand full comment

This may be one of my favorite songs - not just of the Decemberists canon, but of all time. Because I am also so very sad, all the time, but this song always makes me feel a little better.

Expand full comment

So much lovely stuff in these memories. Makes me cherish every silly, stubborn, wonderful, awful moment my wife and I have shared with each other over the years. Thanks again Colin and Carson.

Expand full comment

The hot dog 🌭 story is A++ content. Thank you; omg totally felt that morose young and broke feel from this before; totally identify with the whole besties making each other feel better relationship ; always appreciate a callback to chicken chains .

Expand full comment

Such a beautiful song!!!! Probably my favorite!!! So many of your songs have that, "Excuse me, I'm going to take you right over here... someplace you could've NEVER EXPECTED!!!" That's what spun my head when I heard the first Decemberists song..The Soldiering Life.. wait?? WHAT?? WHERE???

Expand full comment

One of my favorite songs of all time!!

Expand full comment

My husband (whom you and Carson have only just recently met!) proposed to me one afternoon with this song playing in our living room; we’d had our first kiss in 2001, not so long after this song was written. This song means so much to us, and we are so grateful to you for it.

Expand full comment