Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Miguel Tejada-Flores's avatar

Just a few quick thoughts. I love Madame Rigmor, the evil Headmistress of the orphanage (the Kingsley Memorial Home for Destitute Urchins!). In the movie adaptation, she should be played by Tilda Swinton! I was also delighted by the reappearance of the mysterious key - the one the young soldier showed to Ruthie's father (on that fateful night) - the same one she discovered (in Chapter 5) on the ground in her father's study - and which she knows to be the key to the mysterious chest the ship abandoned in the ice!

I keep thinking about the key. It seems really important. I think the moment when Ruthie first picks it up and puts it in her pocket, before leaving home, is a crucial one, one which resonates inside her, even while other things are happening. It may be more 'present' in her unconscious mind than in her thoughts. At the end of Chapter 7, she falls asleep in the trenches at the battle lines. As Chapter 8 begins, Ruthie's half-asleep & half-awake, faintly aware she's being transported in a wagon, away from the battlefield. This is when she dreams - and I'm guessing her dreams would be both scary and mysterious, and would revolve around the mysterious key. Scary dream moments when she uses the key to open a locked cabinet - or a locked door - with something terrifying on the other side, something she's terrified of seeing but also it's unlocking a mystery she's dying to uncover.

Maybe it's not one dream but several short nightmares, each more surreal than the preceding. When she finally awakens and finds herself inside the Orphanage, everything (both the dreams & the key & its mystery) is momentarily forgotten, as she now has a more pressing problem (figuring out where she is and what's happened to her). But later, talking with the bespectacled orphan Vera, as Ruthie tries to tell other girl everything that's happened - she starts to realize just how important the key must be.

At the end of Chapter 7, you mentioned, Colin, that Carson had been planning to draw Ruthie's dream/s, in a graphic novel form, but had never gotten around to doing it - so please consider these notes as my suggestion/s for a possible way in which her dream/s might unfold.

Reading this story is truly engrossing... with so many intriguing details, which the next page, or the next illustration, partially illuminate. Not unlike an anthropologist entering a cleverly camouflaged passageway within an ancient pyramid... which uncovers, inexorably, a new mystery.

Bravo.

Expand full comment

No posts