Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sara Holdren's avatar

Have you ever seen the 1980s nine-hour-long Royal Shakespeare Company Nicholas Nickleby with Roger Rees? It may be hard to get a hold of online (I'm not sure – I've owned the DVD box set since I was a kid)... But I would BEYOND HIGHLY recommend it. I'm a theater-maker, so perhaps I'm a little biased, but Nicholas Nickleby is, no joke, one of the reasons I became one. I feel like it does such a good job at bringing out the best parts of the novel, nailing the humor and the pathos, and making both Dickens's caricatures and his human beings sing. And Roger Rees (despite being, like, 38 and playing 19-year-old Nick!) is so astonishing: His performance, I think, brings home the moral thrust of the novel in a way that maybe even Dickens himself—what with the full-blown picaresque-ness of his early stuff—maybe doesn't quite pull off. I feel like in Rees, what you see is this huge-hearted, young idealist who so believes in the existence of goodness and rightness, and is so affronted when he encounters a world that largely runs on anything but. His outbursts of violence are practically symbolic — it's his/our/the author's moral indignation breaking out of the character physically. And while maybe that's not actually, ultimately, The Way, we can't help but be with him. Part of us also wants SOMEONE to take down the Squeerses and Hawks of the world, right? I think Dickens got more sophisticated about the expression of this same kind of moral outrage at the cruelty and greed of the world as his books went along. There's something young and overly cathartic about Nicholas's aggro moments, but they're also so bound up with the heart of Dickens's project as a social/ethical novelist...

Also, Edward Petherbridge's Newman Noggs is one of the most fantastic performances... like, ever. If you have nine hours to spare, it's truly phenomenal <3

Expand full comment
Ken Priebe's avatar

I just finished POISON FOR BREAKFAST after seeing it in your last post and loved it.

Expand full comment
29 more comments...

No posts